because Pre-paid legal has my banking info
I am very careful who has my banking info. I hate and repel any thought of anyone going into my account to take out of or even put money into automatically, for precisely what you have written here. This stuff happens alot.
I'm thinking you should cancel your bank account and set up another. I'd be too afraid that your account number now is in the wrong hands.
If I ever have anything come out of any of my accounts automatically it would be a charge card, not my bank account. I've done this before and never had a problem. If I did, I would just not pay the questionable charge and contact my CC company.
Too many hands in my checking account would make me nervous. Besides, what if they do a double take and take out an amount twice? If they do this on a charge card, not a problem, but with a checking account, you can have a mess of bounced checks and that would be a problem.
Right now I have World Vision taking out an amount automtically every month for the little girl I sponsor in another country on my credit card. I wouldn't even have them, a reputable company, taking anything out of my bank account.