Conspirarcy aside, I'm not sure if I am surprise or not.
On one hand, we have the Bo-phenomena, where he cant get enough praise for everything he's ever done. He's weakest moments are still strong let down only by boring song choices, but consistent performances and vocal. He's strongest moments is probably the strongest out of all the idols.
Then there's Carrie, with a very strong pure voice and country twang. She has more fans than any other idols this season; she has never been in the bottom three at all - even through her weakest moments. Apart from your comments Jamie (and other comments here), other blogs and comments from other websites supported Carrie more than Bo.
Personally, I am glad Carrie has won, although Bo probably deserves to win it. Is Carrie more marketable than Bo. Carrie's and Vonzell's albums are the ones I will be buying. Again thanks Jamie for your comments and insight. I will see you next year.