Oh dear! Mac vs Windows. just as well not as much time effort and thought goes into the differences between races and nationalities - otherwise we'd have many more international disputes - with so many biased opinions.
A Mac user does so by choice, a Windows user does so by choice, and if each user gets what they expected, wanted and needed from their choice of OS, then what else really matters.
Truth is: neither system is perfect, nor will they ever be because they're man made.
And we've yet to see Apple and Microsoft spend as much time and effort debating this issue. One would suspect they put their time to better use, luckily for us, for there'd be no OS' to compare, otherwise.