That only works if you have a group already started. I want it to always do it from scratch. For example, I have it set up like this:
https://i.imgur.com/U3xPNwy.png
If I open a couple of Explorers and then group them, and then open a couple more they go into the group. But I have to manually go find the first couple and drag them to the group to start the group before new Explorer will go into a group. Just starting from a clean desktop, no Explorer, and hitting Win+E a couple times and they don't group.
This is on Groupy 1.02.
Also I figured out why Chrome was still grouping -- I had hit the three seashells menu and picked "never automatically group", but that doesn't seem to actually do anything. Instead I had to go over to Settings in Groupy go to the exclude list, and manually find the .exe. Why can't I do that from the three seashells? Now I got to go find all the .exe's that I "never automatically group"ed and add them to the exclude list. And of course I can't click in to or copy the path from the never automatically group list... why aren't they the same list with 3 states, "never, sort of, auto".