Ruthven

Join Date 07/2001

What determines when a skin gets "featured"

So I come onto WC today, and finally, I see a Dashboard skin featured right at the top. First time I can remember. And I'm pleased, since Dashboard is what got me here in the first place.

Then I take a closer look. Looks oddly familiar.

Well, that's because it's a skin that was made like six months ago. Now, don't get me wrong, I'm not criticizing the work (generally not my taste, but it's well done for what it is). But why suddenly feature it after six months? Just kind of makes me wonder what it is that determines a skin gets featured. Other than the obvious answer: whatever anyone with access feels like featuring.

Yes, I know I'm generally babbling ... other things distracting me this week, and I'm too stupid to not hit the "Submit" button

Locked Post

Advanced Search

Watch this post

Do not email me updates for this post Email me updates for this post

Successfully updated karma reason!

because six months ago we did not had featured skin

Successfully updated karma reason!

True, Alex ... but they do go back 2 1/2 months. It just kind of got me thinking as to what criteria are applied, if it's anything more than "hey, I like that one."

I also noticed another interesting statistic -- 10% of the PocketBlinds skins have been featured in that time, but only 0.5% of the Dashboard skins. Kinda favors Stardock

(hmm.. hope I'm not sounding bitter or anything here.. that's really not my intention)

Successfully updated karma reason!

davad70

Join Date 03/2001

hmmmmmm.......

Successfully updated karma reason!

Sign Up or Login and this ad disappears!
There are many great features available to you once you register. Sign Up for a free account and browse the forums without ads.

I think it is picked on a "hey, I like this one" criterium. But I agree it should be a rather fresh skin. Why not pick one of yesterday's uploads or so?

Successfully updated karma reason!

adni18

Join Date 05/2001

+70

Glen Eric Reed,
"what it is that determines a skin gets featured"

I think that you post something that every author here in WinCustomize, think about it, very often.
The "hey, I like this one" criterium, it is not fair, in any way.
There are many solutions on this...but we don't have a choice.

Successfully updated karma reason!

In all the skins sites, the featured skin is choosed by the admins. This is not an award, it is just an admin's pick, nothing more then that.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Jafo

Join Date 03/2001

+1845

Yep...it's a 'hey, I like this one' criteria.
Please don't compare it eith DA's 'Daily Deviation' as that is flamed constantly.

The Featured Skin is just something an admin comes across in his/her wanderings and thinks 'hey, I like this one'...

Successfully updated karma reason!

Jafo

Join Date 03/2001

+1845

Dunno where that 'eith' came from....must be a new word.... Spell checker

Successfully updated karma reason!

paxx

Join Date 03/2001

"10% of the PocketBlinds skins have been featured in that time, but only 0.5% of the Dashboard skins." -- by Citizen Glen Eric Reed - 10/30/2001 12:33:25 PM

10% of Pocketblinds skins (30) = 3 skins
3% of Dashboard skins (186) = 5 1/2 skins

So there were more Dashboard skins featured. What is it you were saying again?

Successfully updated karma reason!

paxx

Join Date 03/2001

Oh, wait... 0.5% you said... Where did I get 3%?? Anyway, 0.5% of the Dashboard skins is less than one skin. Hehehe! Man you got robbed, not even a full skin featured?

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frogboy

Join Date 03/2001

+2419

I featured the Dashboard skin. Basically, it's one of those "admin"/wizop perks. They work really REALLY hard on the site. Having such wonderful people helping us day in and day out is probably in my list of top 10 best things in my personal life. Why? Just being associated with such generous people makes me feel supremely honored.

I tend to pick a lot of the picsk, not sure why it ends up that way. I believe any wizop on up can do so. I don't really use Dashboard (I'm a Palm Pilot guy) so POcketPC stuff doesn't tend to get picked that often unless it's something I've used or at least pretty familiar with. Ther'es no inentional bias though.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Blimey. I dunno about anybody else, but having a skin that's more than 24hours old acan be a real breath of fresh air. You might be reminded of an old favourite, or just something you hadn't spotted before...

Blimey. I never rememberb people complaing about custo's screenshot of the week... (apart from when it didn't change for months and months.)

I LIKE knowing what other people are interested in. It's not like the admins say "you are obliged to download the featured skin". If you want something new, it's easy to look in recent submissions yourself. A lot of people don't have as much time as they would like to browse through older submissions, and having older stuff brought to their attention can be reallly handy.

Thanks for having a Featured skin

Successfully updated karma reason!

Jafo

Join Date 03/2001

+1845

Yes, listen to quadrophobe....

Successfully updated karma reason!

listen to just another f**kin' observer

Successfully updated karma reason!

BoXXi

Join Date 03/2001

+393

I'm with Mr. Fours.
If you wanna pick the featured skin, just turn yourself into one of the best skinners around, spend at least 5 years helping the community, get yourself invited to admin on one of the biggest sites in the world, and then you can do the picking! Until then, respect the choices of the experts.

Successfully updated karma reason!

paxx

Join Date 03/2001

Well BoXXi, give yourself a little bit of credit here. The admins here are doing a terrific job, but I wouldn't qualify them as more experts than you or a few other really talented artists around here. No, they are just the admin of this site they have good taste and I erspect their choices, nothing more, really.

BTW: somebody must be doing something right because the same skins always get chosen as featured skins on all the skins sites. Something I've noticed.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Wow, let this thread go overnight, and by the bottom, I'm a disrespectful, bitter loser. Really, I never meant to complain about the featured skin feature at all -- it was just a curious question. I actually do find it interesting to see what's picked, and I wondered if there were any criteria applied besides "I like this." (And now I know if I want to see more Dashboard skins there, I need to buy Frogboy a PocketPC

)

paxx -- I was rounding off on the 0.5% thing, of course. And I don't have a clue where your 3% came from either!

fearoffours -- You make a good point ... I guess featuring an older skin would bring one someone might have missed to their attention (particularly true with Windowblinds, when you've got over 1000 skins to wade through). Today's featured skin is actually a great example of that.. six months old again, but certainly appropriate for Hallowe'en.

BoXXi -- I have no desire to pick the featured skin myself. I'd like to think I'm already one of the best skinners around

(though I haven't been around for 5 years). And WC, one of the biggest sites in the world? Umm, sure, it's popular... in the skinning community. It's not exactly Yahoo.

And again, no disrespect was meant.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Seems like a pretty valid question. And it's nice to know that the community supports the current process of picking the featured skin.

I agree - it's nice to be reminded of some older skins we may have forgotten about.

Successfully updated karma reason!

By the way, the Daily Deviation on DevArt follows the exact same formula as the Featured Skin here. Neither are awards, they're admin picks. Nothing more, nothing less.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Hey, Glen. Thanks for asking the question. It was something that I had wondered about as well.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Jafo

Join Date 03/2001

+1845

Some of these 'featured skins' are chosen by the world's greatest skinners, but others are chosen by me. [I provide a balance]....

Successfully updated karma reason!

Glen - that's cool, apologies if we took your post a little out of context

Successfully updated karma reason!

paxx

Join Date 03/2001

Yes, and not all admins are skinners at all. A website needs different people with different talents for admins.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Thanks for the understanding -- it really was an innocent question. You'll know it when my questions aren't innocent

And don't sell yourself short, Jafo. You probably hit a larger percentage of good skins with what you've posted ... I post everything I do -- no separating the wheat from the chaff for me (um, replace that with a better cliche, will ya?.. my mind isn't functioning quite right).

Someone remind me in the future -- community theatre and message boards don't mix the week that you're doing a show. I'm tired, posting on here more than ever before, but I don't think I've been making much sense....

Successfully updated karma reason!

Paxx, it's true. Not all the admins are skinners. I have admin access (under KarmaGirl) but I haven't used it a lot yet. However, I do have a fine art photography degree, so it is very easy for me to appreciate the talent that goes into these skins. You don't need to be a "skinner" to know what a good skin is.

Successfully updated karma reason!