I checked it, While it is not a bad theme, my suggestions would be to lay off the border \ bevel thickness, The font is.. well, I dont like it and it causes text outside button borders in some cases. Try to finesse your 3D Light and shadow colors a bit better they are too light and too dark either side of the Buttonface shade and try and use less glowy'ness throughout. Try a bit off gaussian blur on some of the jagged edges (.02) is usually good. The Titlebar frame does not match up with the left and right frames. The text shadowing on the inactive titlebar also needs some work.Lastly the gradient light to dark stroke around buttons to me sorta cheapens the look and is used a lot by folks that are new to theming and is usually a sign that you haven't taken experimentation in layer styles very far. Looks like it actually is caused because you havent resized you "glass" layer inside the stroked edge. Drag left and right sides of your glass layer inside so that the entire border is black.
What i see is someone who is progressing nicely per theme but still has a ways to go. Great themes arent designed quickly and learning to make great themes doesnt happen overnight either.
I would suggest taking way more time to work on a theme as opposed to trying to do them quickly and always remember that in a lot of cases, less..is more.
I know its hard to take critique but sooner or later, if you let it, it will sink in. Good for you to speak up and demand some critique, that can take some nerve but shows a willingness to want to improve your game.
Keep up the good work and I hope this has helped. I gave it 3 of 5 stars.
