My sentiments pretty much mirror the comments made by vStyler in #6.
If I need the temp outside I can quickly pull up weather.com or any one of a million sites, or simply look at the thermometer. If I want to see the weather forecast I pull it up, look at it and I'm done with it. There is no practical reason to keep a weather widget running all the time. If the weather is changing that quickly I should think it time to seek shelter.
Time and calendar... Yep, it's right there on my systray. I check my email in outlook and my calendar events are in outlook as well.
Widget media players are nice, but honestly, If I am listening to music, my stereo does a much better job and sounds better than my PC. If I need to listen to an mp3 or cd on my PC, well... WMP is there, it does ALL I need it to do.
Yes, RomanDA's thread says quite a bit on this. (has stardock even acknowledged the thread yet? The last I looked it was being ignored like the plague, from SD)
I think the only thing that is going to make Widgets a success is breaking away from the normal and routine type of objects that are being created, and find a new whiz-bang popularity item. The only ones that I have seen that are even approaching this realm are Vad and Roman. The average skinner just does not posses the coding skills. These guys do possess both.
If Stardock is worried about the future of DX in a widget capacity I would think the logical thing to do would be to follow through on one of your "How Stardock let down the community" items. Get some professional, quality documentation out there for the products. Coding is something that is too complex for the average power user even unless proper, well structured documentation is provided. Tutorials, vids, the whole works.
PLEASE, let's not have any Weather Widget authors get in a snit about this either. Their work is fine and they make some beautiful pieces.
Carry on...