homeryulo

Join Date 06/2004

New Rating System

wincustomize needs it badly

another disappointment from me....I was excited submitting my new work "Samurai" and had nice grade (8) from fair administrators but after a while it only averaged 5 from members. I think the rating system has a bit of politics here. No wonder talented folks is leaving this site. Dont get me wrong...I respect your opinions but 8 to 5 is a bit strange isnt it. Well its okey for now, I have deleted my work already so dont bother. If you want to see it, just visit this link and leave responsible comments.

http://www.deviantart.com/deviation/31504238/

Thank you! Oh and yeah! This site badly needs a new rating system.

Locked Post

Advanced Search

Watch this post

Do not email me updates for this post Email me updates for this post

Successfully updated karma reason!

PoSmedley

Join Date 04/2005

+788

I have had this happen as well. I am not sure how it all works, but when it was a big drop like that, I brought it to the attention of the mods and a few times it was corrected.

My understanding is that the original rating carries the most weight and the rest of the ratings strength is determined by the ranking of who is rating (Journeyman, Master Apprentice, etc) I believe the mods can see who is rating what and how, and will handle things if they seem unfair.

Where you post is your business, but that is a nice wall and I'd like to see it back here along with your future work. I have watched my own stuff go up and down more often than Tom Cruise's popularity.

I'm sure someone will come along with a better explanation that is more hopeful. It's not as screwed up a rating system as you think it is.

With over half your skins at a rating of 9 or 8 (which is excellent compared to mine and some others) I wouldn't get so upset over one. The consistent quality of your work speaks for itself.

Successfully updated karma reason!

thank you Po`s Smedly, your words are encouraging. But I guess I woudnt consider reposting it again here or maybe some of my works for some time. I need to cool my temper a little bit..hehe.I experience this a lot of times and after a long time not submitting here I was disappointed that it seemd never changed. Thanks anyway.

Successfully updated karma reason!

WOM

Join Date 01/2002

+253

Peoples likes and dislikes vary. As Po said, email a supper wizop or jafo and it could have been looked into. If ya was screwed, then it would have been corrected. If not, would have just cost ya some time emailing. For the record, I thought it was ok, not my style, but as I said, peoples tastes vary.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Sign Up or Login and this ad disappears!
There are many great features available to you once you register. Sign Up for a free account and browse the forums without ads.

The rating system is the same as it's always been. Nothing is judged by it's quality here. It is judged by whether or not you are a brown noser, well liked by moderators and/or members of the community, or whether the moderator at the time of ratng, likes the style of it. Oh and if you happen to be part of the "in crowd". I have held this opinion back for far too long in hopes of something changing, but alas, it never will. I can just see the berating I will get now, and so be it. I am tired of sitting on the fence with my mouth closed while I watch good works and people be run into the ground.
The thing I find funny about the ratings that I have been given lately is how much they have changed, in other words they are now below what they should be ever since I renewed my subscription. A coincidence? I think not. And I have seen many wonderful pieces be rejected here. It's a power game. You either play along or you get squashed like a bug.
As a Webmaster of another skinning site I am inviting you to upload your work there. You and your work will be a wonderful addition to our site and appreciated and accepted whether we like you or your style or not. http://www.skinnalicious.net/

Successfully updated karma reason!

i did not bother e-mailing the administrators coz i think I wouldnt stop the problem by just adjusting the rate...the real problem starts in the commnity and so I prefered posting it in the forum...thanks a lot for the comments.

Successfully updated karma reason!

RomanDA

Join Date 12/2003

+147

clwoods,

Nothing is judged by it's quality here. It is judged by whether or not you are a brown noser,

I dont know, I dont know who is rating my skins, i have no idea how i would even find out who is rating them. Also, I rarely look at the nick on a skin, i look at the skin, and to be honest i dont rate a lot of skins unless they are really well done, i used to rate some that i thought were crap as 1's but i gave that up, it doesnt matter to me.

On my skins, i look at the comments to see what people THINK not what they rate something. Id rather get a "looks good, but id like it better if you moved this, or changed that" then "love it" or "hate it", be detailed, tell me what you like. The rating is just something i see when i look at "my skins" and i dont really care, some things i think should be low end up high, and vice-versa.

I dont know about the BN's, i know there are people who want to be Ops and if that's your goal, GLWT. My Goal is journeyman, and if i make it i want there to be no doubt its deserved not given.

Successfully updated karma reason!

I no longer have any goals here. I am very busy at another website I am a webmaster at. The only reason I care about ratings is if it isn't an 8 or higher almost no one will see it and that is not fair.

Successfully updated karma reason!

homeryulo the ratings on that wall were...[in order] ...8, 3, 3, 7.

The '8' was the mod's [we have access to all the numbers]. The others were simply one star less than 'average' and one star more than 'average', quite acceptable in terms of reasonable opinion.

All raters were your contemporaries...ie. they were not new and/or naive. User ID numbers are of assistance there.

Had you left it public a bit longer [it was only made visible yesterday, my time] the ratings/opinions would have levelled out to a quite comfortable median....and IF there were a serious anomaly it could/would have been looked into...as we are wont to do...

Cindi ...presumption/s of 'brown-nosing' being an influence on the part of the site moderators is quite unfair, and unfounded.

I trust as Webmaster on skinnalicious.net you won't be targetted by similar disdain.

Regarding your own ratings....if there appears to be something 'different' about them recently simply drop me an email linking to the ones of concern and I'll investigate. It's what I do...

Successfully updated karma reason!

for me I really dont care a lot about the ranking of members..journeyman, apprentice, etc.. For me quality, and talent is more important in any skinning community. Skinning community is not yet as popular as in any other business out there and so I really think we should try our best to impress other people for them to join us.

And also degrading your work as if it is a crap is not so cool at all.

Successfully updated karma reason!

And, yes Jafo, you have always been fair to me. But unfortunately you and another person here I will keep private, are not the only ones running this place. I don't care about the rating except that it keeps it from being shared with everyone if it isn't an 8 or better. I do not want to get into a debate over the rating system as it will not change a thing. If I ever suffer this kind of disdain, I will be sure I deserve it.

Successfully updated karma reason!

I believe you can change what level of rated skins you want to show up by going to your "My Account" and selecting "Show skins with this rating or higher:" any where from ALL to 5 stars.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Not if you aren't registered Hank. But, it's okay. I will not say anything else in this thread about it. I spoke what was on my mind and now I feel better.

Successfully updated karma reason!

WOM

Join Date 01/2002

+253

Cindi, its or used to be a 7 for walls if your talking about being seen by visitors. For other skins, it will vary by the skin I was told.

And we are admins, not webmasters.....

web·mas·ter (wbmstr)

noun

A person whose occupation is designing, developing, marketing websites.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Interesting post!

Vagrant WOM, I doubt that WOM

Successfully updated karma reason!

I have webmaster rights and that is my title. I am one of the 5 people who built the new site. My husband, Merle and I with the help of Cliff and Chris. It was us and us alone.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Robbie_Boy

Join Date 03/2005

+63

this has allways been a problem, my skin solaire dark 2.2 was 4 stars for a long time then whent down, don't know why it seemed that everyone liked it and i hoped it would goto 4 to 4 and a half stars (8-9)but someone had better idears.

but when i look at the downloads it makes me smile over 26,000 downloads now and still going and all the nice comment's tooo

BUT it dose upset you i know!!!!!!!!
there will allways be someone out to mess with things and upset people....

Successfully updated karma reason!

WOM

Join Date 01/2002

+253

Hum, didn't know that.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Phoon

Join Date 10/2001

+382

Homeryulo, for what its worth, I rated that piece with 3 stars (which translates to a 6 numerical). I liked it, but frankly it was not the same caliber as many of your other works and pales in comparison to Bilog.
Different ideas and designs are quite refreshing and the ability to do so separates the average from the great. Just not all ideas and flavors will be received as others have been.
So buck up, resubmit that wall, and move on.

Successfully updated karma reason!

PoSmedley

Join Date 04/2005

+788

if it isn't an 8 or higher almost no one will see it and that is not fair

Out of 150+ uploads, about 16 got an 8 and not all from the start. With 42,000+ downloads, only 5 of those 8's are in the top ten. I have things with a 4 or 5 rating that have been downloaded more than some of the 8's. I can't speak for anyone else, but I almost never browse by ratings. I know when I first started coming here and browsed by ratings, I found out I was missing a lot of great work.

I believe you can change what level of rated skins you want to show up by going to your "My Account" and selecting "Show skins with this rating or higher:" any where from ALL to 5 stars

Mine is always set at 1. I wanna see it all!

Successfully updated karma reason!

If you are creating your work for ratings, that is sad indeed. If you yourself consider it a good piece and you are happy with it and feel you did a good enough job to upload it, that should be the end of it. A high rating doesn't make it better, a low rating doesn't make it worse...it's the same damn work! Get over this ratings stuff people!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Homeryulo, for what its worth, I rated that piece with 3 stars (which translates to a 6 numerical).

Phoon....it actually translated to the '7' I mentioned in post #8 ....

Jafo loves being 'pedantic'....

Successfully updated karma reason!

Cavan1

Join Date 08/2004

+173

Hey Po, the 8 clwoods is talking about is for wallpapers.

Successfully updated karma reason!

PoSmedley

Join Date 04/2005

+788

Then I would say that 'especially with wallpapers' the ratings don't mean much. You are talking about what a person is going to be staring at for a good bit of the time they are on the computer. They are going to pick what they like, no matter what, over what the rating is. Not everyone likes all the abstract glassy tech stuff that is created or the cute lil cartoon crap I do. There are people right here in this thread with WP's that have a 5 or 6 rating with more downloads than all my wallpapers put together.

An artist is recognized for his style and quality of work, and then more so by those that favor that particular style. One of my best rated walls at a 7 is a bunch of cartoon cats. I know damn well Jafo isn't rushing to throw that on his desktop.

I really think personal taste has a lot more to do with the download process than ratings.

Successfully updated karma reason!

for me it really doesnt matter if my wall has been rated low initially...if you check my galleries, many of my walls have a rate of 5 and 6 and I realy dont mind. I really put a big deal on the Moderators ratings..I believe that their ratings bear the biggest weight coz they are fair in any angle. Thats why when they rated my work 8, I was confident that my wall is not that bad to be rated lower than 6...thats why I was disappointed...and to Phoon,thank you very much for giving my work a rate of 7..that is very acceptable and I appreciate your comment and support

I created my work not for rating, but in a wallpaper section you need to have at least a rating of 8 inorder for other unregistered members to appreciate it..and that is what all of us wallpaper uploaders are really hoping for...and to boss0190, dont get me wrong but being happy and contented with your work is always not the case in uploading skins here..we can just draw a circle,put a little color and texture and we may find ourselves already contented and happy....but we should consider first if other people may also appreciate it...it means quality control..and for me its very important if your are a responsible uploader.

Some people draw their inspirations from making people happy and not only themselves, thats why its important for us that our work could reach out to as many people as possible...thats is a big point.and that is why its always been a great deal for me. thanks

Successfully updated karma reason!

Jafo, I appologize for any offense you have taken from what I said. It was not directed at you. As I said before, you have always been fair to me.

Successfully updated karma reason!